If you’ve been in the vacation rental industry for long, you already know that OTAs can be an important part of a vacation rental distribution strategy. They certainly help property managers reach travelers who might not know the brand, attract bookings during slower periods, and increase visibility across markets. But when a large share of your reservations comes from a small number of third-party platforms, that reach comes with real trade-offs. OTA commissions and service fees affect booking revenue, and changes to the platform search and ranking systems can make performance harder to predict.
The issue isn’t OTAs. It’s relying on them so heavily that channel cost and platform decisions have an outsized effect on your business.
For a mid-sized vacation rental property management company, the impact can be substantial. A 150-unit portfolio may generate significant booking revenue each year, so even a modest difference in channel costs can add up. The key is to understand what you’re paying, what you’re receiving in return, and how much of your business depends on channels you don’t control.
To see how quickly the costs can add up, let’s look at the current fee structures for three of the most widely used OTAs. Consider that 150-unit portfolio mentioned earlier with an average of $60,000 in annual rental revenue per unit, for a total of $9,000,000 in annual rental revenue. If that revenue came entirely from a single platform, here’s how the fees might compare*:
|
Fee rate |
~8% |
~15% |
~15.5% |
|
Illustrative annual fees |
$720,000 |
$1,350,000 |
$1,395,000 |
That's the bigger point: whichever platform you look at, when millions of dollars in booking revenue flow through a third-party channel, even a percentage-based fee becomes a significant operating expense, and for portfolios that draw bookings from more than one OTA, as most do, those fees compound across channels.
Of course, very few portfolios run 100% of their revenue through a single platform, so here’s a more realistic view. If 70% of that same $9,000,000 comes through OTAs, that’s $6,300,000 in OTA bookings. At an average fee of around 15%, that’s roughly $945,000 a year in fees. A handy rule of thumb: every $1 million in OTA bookings costs roughly $150,000 in fees at a 15% rate.
*The average revenue per home represented above serves as an illustrative example, and assumes all revenue flows through that single platform. Actual rates can vary. Vrbo drops closer to 5% through a connected PMS, and Booking.com can range from 10-25%, depending on the market and property type. Most portfolios spread revenue across multiple channels. OTA fees could be lower than those represented here.
Using the same 150-unit example, moving just 10% of total bookings ($900,000) from an OTA charging 15.5% to direct bookings with roughly 3% in payment processing would save about $112,500 a year. That’s a goal a busy team can picture, and it doesn’t require a complete overhaul of how you do business.
There’s another cost of OTA dependency that doesn’t show up neatly on a P&L statement: the guest relationship. When a traveler books through an OTA, the platform controls much of the booking experience, from the initial search and comparison to the reservation and the communication that follows. The guest may remember where they stayed, but they’re often interacting first and foremost with an OTA, not your brand.
That can make it much harder to build guest relationships, encourage repeat bookings, or convert that traveler into a direct-booking customer you can market to in the future. And that matters beyond this year’s revenue: a guest who returns and books directly can generate significantly more long-term customer value than one you have to reacquire through an OTA.
Why put resources into SEO, building an email list, strengthening brand recognition, or running retargeting campaigns when the majority of your demand is coming through someone else’s platform? If most of your bookings come from OTAs, you’re limited in how much you have to invest in your own vacation rental marketing strategy. It’s an easy pattern to fall into, because the OTA is simply the easiest source of demand. Over time, that creates a cycle of dependency: the OTA generates the bookings, while your own marketing channels remain underutilized. Instead of a diversified booking strategy, a single platform ends up calling all the shots.
Anyone who’s worked with third-party booking platforms is all too aware: Fee structures evolve, algorithms shift, and visibility fluctuates. So if 70% of your revenue comes from one or two OTA platforms, your property management company’s income relies heavily on decisions over which you have no control. A shift in search rankings or fees might be frustrating for a 20-unit operator. For a 150-unit vacation rental portfolio, even a small change in booking volume or distribution costs can seriously impact profitability and revenue, and that’s the real risk: your business remains financially exposed to changes made by platforms you can’t steer.
Your owners are paying attention. More and more, they ask what share of bookings comes direct and how much of their rental income is going to third-party fees. A healthier distribution mix isn’t just good for your bottom line; it strengthens the case you make to prospective owners and gives you a stronger story when it’s time to retain the ones you have.
A balanced vacation rental distribution strategy isn’t about eliminating OTAs. It’s about building a mix of channels that work together. Let the OTAs drive base occupancy and introduce new guests, while you continue to let direct bookings grow year over year. Use Email marketing to give past guests a reason to return, paid search to capture travelers looking for your brand, and your website to convert interest into bookings.
The goal is balance: use OTAs as one source of demand while strengthening the channels and guest relationships your property management business controls.
If your team is already stretched thin, a direct booking strategy can feel like one more thing you don’t have time for. The good news is that reducing OTA dependency doesn’t mean launching a big new initiative. For most mid-sized teams, it starts with a few small, repeatable steps:
While OTAs can be an important part of your booking mix, they shouldn’t be your whole strategy. B2 Collaborative helps mid-sized vacation rental property management companies build sustainable marketing programs that support direct bookings, strengthen guest relationships, and create a more balanced distribution of bookings. From SEO and website content to paid search, retargeting, and email marketing, we work alongside your team to help your brand reach travelers and convert interest into bookings. And because we support both guest and owner marketing, we help you build a distribution story that works for your bottom line and your owners.
Not sure where to start? Pull your last 12 months of bookings by channel and let’s look at your mix together. Read our tactical guide to reduce OTA dependency, explore our guest journey guide, and reference our blog post, 5 Automations Every Vacation Rental Brand Should Have, to learn more about our services, and contact us today!